ALASTAIR DRYBURGH

Pricing Strategies for Consulting Firms and Creative Agencies


Value Based Pricing: Myths, Misapprehensions and Misunderstandings

Value based pricing has been around long enough for misunderstandings and myths to develop. Some of these may be putting you off, or making you feel that it’s not for you. Here are the most common objections. Read, and make your own mind up.

“I Really Can’t See That Our Services Are Worth That Much More”

You can’t. Nobody can see the full value of what they do, any more than they can see the back of their head or see up their own nostrils. We are just too close. It takes an outsider to point out our full value, backed up with a process.

“The Value Of Our Services Can’t Be Quantified”

This is not a problem. There are many forms of value which can’t be quantified; enhancement of reputation for example. If the value is there, even subjectively, clients will pay if the proposition is presented the right way. One of my clients, a digital agency,  does very well offering reassurance. 

“It’s Too Subjective, Too Much Like A Black Art”

This one makes me cross. It simply comes from the people promoting value based pricing being lazy, not having a properly worked out method. I am a former CFO who comes from a family of physicists and engineers. I believe in repeatable, empirically tested processes. The Intelligent Pricing Architecture process is exactly that. 

“If Our Service Is Good Enough, Clients Will See The Value And Pay Us Accordingly”

Unfortunately not. Obviously you need to provide a high quality service, but you also need to present it in a way that convinces others, who see things in a very different way from you. This is something you need to learn, but there is some good news. Compared to the effort it took to learn to do what you do, learning how to get properly paid is a walk in the park. An hour a week for a number of months.

“We Have Too Much Else Golng On To Think About This”

 Be honest. There’s always going to be a lot going on. If you say “we’ll get to this later’” accept that “later” means “never.” The good news is that the process is designed to be very economical of your time. We meet typically once a week for 50 minutes. I do 90% of the hard thinking. The rest of the week you do whatever you would otherwise be doing – managing projects, talking to clients, hunting for new business, writing proposals – but do it more effectively.

“Does This Mean You Guarantee To Produce This Value?”

We sometimes get this question. Here is the answer; you obviously need to put it into the right words for the person you’re talking to.

“No. We can’t offer a guarantee, because there are too many factors which we can’t control. Anyway, if we could guarantee a result of, say, $1,000,000, we would be asking you for $500,000 at least, probably $750,000.

What we are offering is something that moves the odds substantially in your favour. For this you pay a fee which gives you a 10x return, i.e. $100,000.”

What Other People Say

Mark Sherwood Edwards

I engaged Alastair to help me think through how to approach value-based pricing in the context of legal services. Through a series of weekly 1 hour sessions we worked through the best way to articulate the benefits provided to the customer, the different comparisons available for pricing (choosing the right comparator is key), and the best discovery questions to reveal what the customer really values.

Very, very useful. Recommended for anyone who wants to maximise the value they capture.

Mark Sherwood-Edwards, Lawyering for B2B SaaS

“Alastair is skilled at asking the right questions to help unpack the (real) value being offered to clients – and price accordingly. Our work together challenged some of my own assumptions; helped identify the right frames of reference for pricing; and reassure clients about outcomes/benefits. As a marketer I already know about value propositions & pricing. BUT even a seasoned barber shouldn’t cut his own hair … and working with Alastair is another example of when it is beneficial to get help from another expert.”

Matt Day, Meaningful Few

“In the first month, not only did the adjustments we made pay for Alastair’s fees, we identified enough opportunities to pay for the engagement 30 times over the next three years.

We unearthed highly valuable and unique skills that we had been underselling, and now have an entirely new vision for the future of the company. 

We made more progress in an hour a week with Alastair over 4 months than we had in the previous 4 years.”

Sarah Lafferty, Round Earth Consulting

Working with Alastair has had a massive impact already. Moving away from billing hours and £s towards focussing on value has been liberating. It has removed a lot of the noise and given us a lot more confidence in ourselves and the value of what we do. We’re looking forward to the results from 3-4 proposals we have out which are at much higher prices than before.”

Jo Hind, Bird Soup Consultancy

“At Curated we have an ability to look into our clients’ businesses and see things that they can’t because they are too close. It was amazing how an outsider was able to do the same for us, particularly an outsider who draws on multiple different sources. I have never met anyone like Alastair who can bring ideas from psychology, sociology, philosophy and even management theory to bear productively on business issues. We can’t properly calculate the ROI on our work with him because many benefits are still to come, but we are already beyond 10x”

Simon Douglass, Curated Digital